LEGGI
BENI IN PERICOLO
INTERVENTI E RECENSIONI
RASSEGNA STAMPA
COMUNICATI DELLE ASSOCIAZIONI
EVENTI
BIBLIOGRAFIA
STORIA e FORMAZIONE del CODICE DEI BENI CULTURALI E DEL PAESAGGIO
LINK
CHI SIAMO: REDAZIONE DI PATRIMONIOSOS
BACHECA DELLE TESI
per ricevere aggiornamenti sul sito inserisci il tuo indirizzo e-mail
patrimonio sos
in difesa dei beni culturali e ambientali

stampa Versione stampabile

Florence. A Streetcar Named Disaster?
Judith Harris
www.i-Italy.org, 24-02-2008

The birthplace of the Italian Renaissance splits over a "tramvia" that would run within three feet of the Baptistery, which dates from before the year 1000, but is still standing nevertheless.

FLORENCE Walking to an appointment in Florence on Thursday, we found ourselves in snarled and snarling traffic. A mini-Cooper had parked badly by Piazza della Repubblica, blocking a big city bus, unable to turn a corner. The bus had come to a stop, blocking the entire city center. Police arrived. People gathered. Tourists took photos. Meantime traffic fumes, hurtling scooters, honking cars, and frustrated Florentines all built into a crescendo of misery.

Yes, it was just one of the usual urban messes, but with a difference: this is Florence, birthplace of the Italian Renaissance, one of the most elegant cities in the world, and currently one of the most troubled over traffic.


On February 18 Florentines turned out to vote on a controversial referendum over construction of Line 2 of a light railway line improperly called a tram. This Line 2, which in some areas would require steel tubes 21 feet high, would bring the tram line along the roadvisible in the photo taken before the street was given bus lanes and barriersbetween the Baptistery and the Duomo building and the file of Renaissance buildings on the right.

In an open letter to one of the most important Italian cultural websites, www.patrimoniosos.it, Florentine citizen Niccol Fani wrote:

Line 2 calls for the tram to cross right in front of the Baptistery and Duomo, two world-class masterpieces of art. The tracks would run within three feet of the Baptistery, which dates from before the year 1000, but is still standing neverthelessat least up to now. Besides the aesthetic damage to Piazza Duomo (including the electric wires and bulky steel supports for the line), there are serious structural risks deriving from having a tram line so close to the buildings.



Among the arguments in favor of the so-called tramvia (and those in favor of it include labor unions, coop associations and some greens) is that it 2,000 buses a day already go by. It will reduce the smog that discolors the white marble of the Duomo; will reduce vibrations from the heavy buses; will reduce congestion and will, miraculously at the same time, also double the number (today 250,000) of people who presently come into downtown Florence every weekday, with the consequent economic advantages. Besides, the argument goes, many of those now opposing the light train favored it in the past and are doing an undignified about-face.








Those opposing the light train argue that it has been presented as a tram, whereas it is not; that a mini-subway beneath Florence would accomplish the same goals without running tracks past Duomo and Baptistery; that an outlying stretch of the same larger plan for three connected lines has already had a gigantic cost over-run; and that it is as ugly as sin, in a city whose very essence is beauty.

And so the two sides are lined up against each other. Mario Razzanelli, a local politician and successful businessman, has been battling against the tram project for nine years and was one of the chief promoters of the referendum. He does not intend to give up his campaign.

My battle against the tram in Florence began in 1999. This tram will not solve the problemit will complicate the situation. Its a battle between people who love Florence and those who would destroy it, a battle between reason and folly. All great cities have subways under their buildings, one young man protested.

Another opposing the construction is the distinguished Prof. Antonio Paolucci, the recently appointed director of the Vatican Museums. A native of Florence, Paolucci is former Minister of Culture for Italy and former superintendent of archaeology for Florence, and also the author of a book on the Baptistery. Paolucci has never been a conservative, but in opposing the construction of a train line through the heart of Florence, he alienated many on the left because the conservatives of Alleanza Nazionale, who include Razzanelli, also opposed construction.

But then so did every single Florentine with whom I spoke, from travel agent to student, tobacconist, shop keeperand the younger they were, the stronger their opposition. There is no doubt that the chaos and smog raise hackles, and feelings ran understandably high, to put it mildly. Florence on the verge of a nervous breakdown over the tram, went one headline.

So, to the vote. The press agency Adnkronos gave the figures: those voters opposing construction were 53.84% while 48.3% were in favor. That seems clear enough: the citizens voted to block the tram. But it did not work that way, for less that 50% of those entitled to vote turned out at the polls, and so the supporters of construction claim they had won even though those voting demonstrated their desire to block it. Here too there are quarrels: the mayor insists that the referendum must respect national criteria, which set a 50% turnout treshold for a referendum to be valid; the opponents of the tram say that local referenda go by different rules and that hence they won.

One element that has been ignored until now is that the tram would also alter the destiny of Florences tiny Victorian-era Protestant cemetery, in which many prominent English writers are buried, including Elizabeth Barrett Browning and Frances Trollope. The cemetery lies on a small knoll rising just outside the line where Florences city walls ran until demolished to make way for a broad avenue of heavy traffic. Until recently to reach itand it is a favorite of tourists from all over the worldmeant risking your life. Today zebra stripes make it at least possible, but the proposed tram would entirely cut off this romantic vestige of all those Florentine rooms with views.




http://www.i-italy.org/1351/florence-streetcar-named-disaster


news

11-10-2019
RASSEGNA STAMPA aggiornata al giorno 11 ottobre 2019

04-10-2019
Unicredit mette all'asta da Christie's capolavori della sua collezione

14-09-2019
Da Artribune: Franceschini sospende i decreti Bonisoli

05-09-2019
Franceschini, il primo appuntamento al Museo della Liberazione di via Tasso

02-09-2019
Giuliano Volpe: Ci piacerebbe un ministro più educato

29-08-2019
Da Finestre sull'arte vi segnaliamo...

25-08-2019
Sul Financial Times si parla dei provvedimenti Bonisoli

22-08-2019
Trasferito il Soprintendente di Pisa che si era opposto alle bancarelle in piazza dei Miracoli

20-08-2019
In Finestre sull'arte: Gli accorpamenti della riforma Bonisoli affosseranno definitivamente i musei piccoli?

20-08-2019
Caos musei. Nel sito Emergenza Cultura vi segnaliamo...

16-08-2019
Da Finestre sull'arte: Musei, tutti gli accorpamenti decisi da Bonisoli

14-08-2019
Bonisoli firma decreto musei, ecco cosa prevede

01-07-2019
APPELLO - Per il parco archeologico dell'Appia Antica

30-06-2019
Documento dell'API sulla riforma del Ministero: riorganizzazioni perenni

27-06-2019
La FCdA per il Museo Etrusco di Villa Giulia e il Parco Archeologico dell'Appia Antica

26-06-2019
Firenze, l'annuncio di Bonisoli: "Accademia formerà polo unico con gli Uffizi"

21-06-2019
Lorenzo Casini sulla riforma del Ministero: Linsostenibile leggerezza ovvero la nuova riorganizzazione del Ministero per i beni e le attività culturali (Mibac)

05-06-2019
Alinari. Quale destino per la più grande raccolta museale di fotografie in Italia? Un comunicato della SISF

30-05-2019
Bando per il premio Silvia Dell'Orso 2019: scadenza 30 settembre

07-05-2019
Dal blog di Carlo Pavolini: Luca Nannipieri e l'abolizione delle Soprintendenze

25-03-2019
Pisa. Bonisoli: Sarà trovata soluzione per ambulanti ma non in piazza Miracoli

25-03-2019
E' mancato questa mattina Andrea Emiliani

28-02-2019
Associazione culturale Silvia Dell'Orso: VIII edizione di Visioni d'arte

26-02-2019
Mai più bancarelle in piazza dei Miracoli. Firmate l'appello

14-02-2019
Appello. Contro lo smantellamento dello Stato Italiano

13-01-2019
Per unarcheologia fuori dallimpasse. Lettera al Ministro Bonisoli di API (Archeologi Pubblico Impiego)

11-01-2019
Sulla riforma delle Soprintendenze e dei musei di archeologia. Dichiarazione di archeologi accademici Lincei

29-12-2018
Per un rafforzamento delle soprintendenze uniche

29-12-2018
A proposito dell'appello agli archeologi: "Firme e coerenza" di Pier Giovanni Guzzo

18-12-2018
APPELLO AGLI ARCHEOLOGI

Archivio news