LEGGI
BENI IN PERICOLO
INTERVENTI E RECENSIONI
RASSEGNA STAMPA
COMUNICATI DELLE ASSOCIAZIONI
EVENTI
BIBLIOGRAFIA
STORIA e FORMAZIONE del CODICE DEI BENI CULTURALI E DEL PAESAGGIO
LINK
CHI SIAMO: REDAZIONE DI PATRIMONIOSOS
BACHECA DELLE TESI
per ricevere aggiornamenti sul sito inserisci il tuo indirizzo e-mail
patrimonio sos
in difesa dei beni culturali e ambientali

stampa Versione stampabile

What Is the Antiquities Act and Why Does President Trump Want to Change It?
By TATIANA SCHLOSSBERG
APRIL 26, 2017


The northernmost boundary of the Bears Ears National Monument, along the Colorado River, in southeastern Utah is one of the national monuments to be reviewed by the Interior Department.


President Trump on Wednesday ordered the Interior Department to review the size and scope of national monuments larger than 100,000 acres created since 1996. He wants recommendations on whether any of those large tracts should be scaled back by presidential authority or by Congress.

Mr. Trump, signing the order at the Interior Department, described the designations as a massive federal land grab and ordered the agency to review and reverse some of them.

Its time to end these abuses and return control to the people, the people of Utah, the people of all of the states, the people of the United States, the president said.

National monuments are designated by presidents under a century-old law called the Antiquities Act. What does the law do, what changes in it does President Trump want and what lands might be affected?

When did all this get started?
The law was enacted in 1906 to prevent looting of Indian artifacts from archaeological sites. The act has mostly been used since then by presidents to turn public land into national monuments protected forever from commercial development or future mineral exploitation.

It was in the news at the end of the Obama administration after President Barack Obama created several national monuments, setting aside millions of acres on land and sea. At the time, some Republicans in Congress said they wanted to reform the act, which they said encouraged federal government overreach, a claim that has dogged the law since it was adopted.

President Theodore Roosevelt, who signed the Antiquities Act into law, created 18 monuments, including the Grand Canyon and Olympic National Park in Washington, totaling more than a million acres. According to data from the National Park Service, fifteen other presidents from both parties have designated a total of 170 national monuments, including marine monuments.

The president can make national monuments only from land already controlled by the federal government, and the act generally does not change how the land is used, said Lisa Dale, the associate director of the Yale Center for Environmental Law and Policy. If leases for mining, ranching, drilling or logging already exist on land to be made into a national monument, they can continue, but new leases probably wont be allowed, she said.

Most legal scholars and historians agree that the Antiquities Act does not give the president the authority to revoke previous national monument designations, but a president can change the boundaries of a national monument. Congress can convert a national monument into a national park, which it has done many times.

Who could be hurt by possible changes?
Most Americans support protection of public lands. According to a 2016 study from Harvards Kennedy School of Government, more than 93 percent of respondents said that historical sites, public lands and national parks should be protected for current and future generations.

PRIVACY POLICY OPT OUT OR CONTACT US ANYTIME
Char Miller, an environmental historian at Pomona College, said that if national monuments were diminished by the review process, it would actually hurt the people opponents of the law are claiming to protect.

Some designations are controversial, as was Mr. Obamas designation of the Bears Ears National Monument in Utah in December. Republicans argued that it would hurt the local economy, but Mr. Miller said wilderness areas can bring in tourists who support local businesses.

Ryan Zinke, the interior secretary, said he would provide an interim review of the monuments in 45 days and would make specific recommendations about Bears Ears.

At three of the national monuments Mr. Obama created or expanded Bears Ears, Katahdin Woods and Waters National Monument in Maine, and Papahanaumokuakea Marine National Monument in Hawaii special effort was made to include Indian tribes in the designation process and continuing management of these areas.

Ms. Dale said that reducing these monuments or changing them would have a chilling effect on tribal federal relations when it comes to protecting landscapes.

Who would it help?
If existing national monuments are reduced in size, it could benefit extractive industries like oil and gas, mining, logging, as well as ranching, Mr. Miller said, because the government could grant more leases on federal land. Given the Trump administrations recent actions including lifting the moratorium on drilling on federal lands and the obligation to limit methane emissions on public lands officials might be eyeing new fossil fuel leases on previously protected land, though Mr. Zinke said he was not predisposed to make any such recommendation about the monument land.

Mr. Zinke said that he has heard claims that some monument designations have ended in lost wages, lost jobs and reduced public access. But he added that he believed some jobs probably have been created by recreational opportunities.

Some of the opposition to the national monuments may be ideological. Western ranchers and sportsmen have long complained about what they see as federal land grabs that limit their access to millions of acres of public territory. However, a majority of Americans in Western states, home to vast tracts of federal land, support maintaining public land.

No one loves their public lands more than I, Mr. Zinke said. You can love them as much, but not more than I do.

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/26/climate/antiquities-act-federal-lands-donald-trump.html


news

06-12-2019
RASSEGNA STAMPA aggiornata al giorno 6 DICEMBRE 2019

04-12-2019
Libero riuso delle riproduzioni di beni culturali: articolo di Daniele Manacorda sul "Giornale dell'arte"

14-11-2019
Cosa succederà alla Biblioteca Guarneriana di S. Daniele del Friuli? Un appello dei cittadini al sindaco

04-10-2019
Unicredit mette all'asta da Christie's capolavori della sua collezione

14-09-2019
Da Artribune: Franceschini sospende i decreti Bonisoli

05-09-2019
Franceschini, il primo appuntamento al Museo della Liberazione di via Tasso

02-09-2019
Giuliano Volpe: Ci piacerebbe un ministro più educato

29-08-2019
Da Finestre sull'arte vi segnaliamo...

25-08-2019
Sul Financial Times si parla dei provvedimenti Bonisoli

22-08-2019
Trasferito il Soprintendente di Pisa che si era opposto alle bancarelle in piazza dei Miracoli

20-08-2019
In Finestre sull'arte: Gli accorpamenti della riforma Bonisoli affosseranno definitivamente i musei piccoli?

20-08-2019
Caos musei. Nel sito Emergenza Cultura vi segnaliamo...

16-08-2019
Da Finestre sull'arte: Musei, tutti gli accorpamenti decisi da Bonisoli

14-08-2019
Bonisoli firma decreto musei, ecco cosa prevede

01-07-2019
APPELLO - Per il parco archeologico dell'Appia Antica

30-06-2019
Documento dell'API sulla riforma del Ministero: riorganizzazioni perenni

27-06-2019
La FCdA per il Museo Etrusco di Villa Giulia e il Parco Archeologico dell'Appia Antica

26-06-2019
Firenze, l'annuncio di Bonisoli: "Accademia formerà polo unico con gli Uffizi"

21-06-2019
Lorenzo Casini sulla riforma del Ministero: Linsostenibile leggerezza ovvero la nuova riorganizzazione del Ministero per i beni e le attività culturali (Mibac)

05-06-2019
Alinari. Quale destino per la più grande raccolta museale di fotografie in Italia? Un comunicato della SISF

30-05-2019
Bando per il premio Silvia Dell'Orso 2019: scadenza 30 settembre

07-05-2019
Dal blog di Carlo Pavolini: Luca Nannipieri e l'abolizione delle Soprintendenze

25-03-2019
Pisa. Bonisoli: Sarà trovata soluzione per ambulanti ma non in piazza Miracoli

25-03-2019
E' mancato questa mattina Andrea Emiliani

28-02-2019
Associazione culturale Silvia Dell'Orso: VIII edizione di Visioni d'arte

26-02-2019
Mai più bancarelle in piazza dei Miracoli. Firmate l'appello

14-02-2019
Appello. Contro lo smantellamento dello Stato Italiano

13-01-2019
Per unarcheologia fuori dallimpasse. Lettera al Ministro Bonisoli di API (Archeologi Pubblico Impiego)

11-01-2019
Sulla riforma delle Soprintendenze e dei musei di archeologia. Dichiarazione di archeologi accademici Lincei

29-12-2018
Per un rafforzamento delle soprintendenze uniche

Archivio news